Thursday, September 2, 2010

fungible facts

Met a lovely, young man last night who was in town for a UN event on disabilities. Earnest and articulate, he explained how, unsurprisingly, the UN had a treaty (or protocol, convention - however they call them) on disability rights and, even less surprisingly, the US had not officially signed on.

Okay, so we don't like being pinned down by a protocol, I said, but how's our track record on disability rights compared to other countries?

Not too good, he explained: "When you look at the employee disability cases that go to the courts, more than 90% are decided in favor of the employer."

Well, case closed. Apparently there are tons of people out there with disabilities that are not having their rights upheld.

But, I asked, couldn't you say the opposite? That since the courts are finding that most of the cases brought to them are without merit, clearly employers are by and large following the law? If you said, instead, that the courts were finding 90% of the cases in favor of the workers, then you'd have evidence that employers were disregarding their staff's disability rights.

Blank stare. I felt bad - he really was earnest and nice. So I back-pedaled: maybe it's not a matter of percentages, but total numbers, I suggested? If 90% of 100 cases brought to federal court were thrown out, then no biggie. But if 90% of 100,000 cases were tossed, then - yes - that would be something to be concerned about. He brightened up - and will now hopefully brush up on his facts and maybe even use them more carefully.

Saturday, August 21, 2010

what pulls our purse strings

Aidwatch pointed out yesterday that, while Americans had shelled out $560 million in donations to Haiti two and a half weeks after its earthquake, in the same amount of time we had only raised $5 million for Pakistanis suffering from the flood disaster.

At first glance, that's a staggering difference in charitability and one can't help conjecture - as Aidwatch does - what's at root of the donation gap: distance from home? unfamiliarity (due, among other things, to the fact that Pakistan is not a tourist destination)? distrust of Pakistani charities? a media bias? or is it just anti-Islam sentiment?

We'll probably never know, but Aidwatch mentions that at least part of what drives donations are the number of lives lost - and it just so happens that while Americans had given 100 times more to Haiti, Haiti had also suffered 100 times larger death toll.

There's also another explanation: randomness. Network theorists tell us that "trends" (that is, any behavior that catches on, including charitable giving for a disaster) act in random, unpredictable ways. In a complex system, it's often not one or two causes that can explain why you get an "information cascade" - rather it's a lot of small factors that add up. It's not a satisfying explanation, but it may be the closest to the truth.

Wednesday, August 18, 2010

transparency at any cost

The LA Times reports this week that Arne Duncan, US education secretary, thinks teachers evaluations should be public. "What's there to hide?" Arne asks.

Arne's simple question hides the complexity of transparency. Among democracy lovers, transparency - opening up the goings on of government institutions - is usually thought of as an indisputably good thing. And that makes sense - if there's nothing wrong, why would you want to hide it?

But transparency - like everything else - only works if it aligns with human incentives and behavior. Sometimes things work better with transparency. Sometimes not. Running an organization, like a school, is a good example of the latter.

If you run your own company, you know you have some employees who deliver more than others. Managing that gap takes finesse; you want to keep the better employee fired up while figuring out how to improve the other employee's game. You may experiment with performance pay, mentoring or creating teams that have their own incentives. At the same time, you've got to make sure your clients are served. One thing's clear; there's no way all your clients can work with the best employee. So you have to make choices. Now let's say your employees' success rates are made public. You've got a problem: everyone will want to work with the top employee, none with the 2nd rate worker. The 2nd guy is just as likely to become demoralized as energized by this new public information; either way, office morale and team-spirit are sure to plummet. Any incentives you've worked out to improve the 2nd employee's work get lost now that all eyes are on his numbers.

I've just given a negative picture of what transparency may deliver; there are likely many positive responses and scenarios that could occur as well. The point is that, when you add transparency, the picture changes - in many potentially complex ways. If you're Arne you'd want to think "in what ways will transparency shift the incentives and dynamics in schools?" and "In the end, are students better or worse off?" It's not a no-brainer.


Sunday, August 15, 2010

can you be a savvy optimist?

Philosopher Richard Scruton, in making a case for the virtue of pessimism, explains why we tend to be optimistic idealists (as summarized by reviewer Richard King):

"Scruton identifies seven fallacies that he sees as underwriting false hope. Put briefly, these translate into a tendency to always look on the bright side, a belief that freedom is hampered by law, an unwillingness to countenance refutation, a belief that failure in one human quarter is directly connected to success in another, an inclination to impose solutions rather than letting them evolve over time, the idea that human history has an endpoint, and the tendency to assume agreeable concepts such as liberty and equality are mutually reinforcing."

We picked these tendencies up as hunter-gatherers when, presumably, they served a purpose. Now they can rush us into over-exuberant campaigns to perfect the world. As a world-perfecting ideologue, the challenge is to figure out which instincts can buoy our drive to make the world a better place - and which might lead us down blind alleys.

Friday, July 23, 2010

another lesson in less is more?

The US and South Korea are gearing up to show North Korea some military muscle - and North Korea is gearing up to throw some version of a temper tantrum in response.

At this time I'm giving the US State Department the benefit of the doubt that their planned military exercise will have some short or long-term positive impact on North and South relations, but now I'm having a hard time seeing it. I suspect, instead, that the US may be victim of the "do something" bias - that is, do something is better than doing nothing. But sometimes doing nothing is the better way to go.

in praise of stovepipes

The Washington Post two year investigation that laid out the vast complexity and "overgrowth" of the US intelligence system has generally been received with gasps of disbelief and sighs of despair. Certainly, at first glance one wonders how 1,271 government organizations and 1,931 private companies could possibly coordinate activities and efficiently share information. Surely they must be doing duplicative work. Even worse, if not all the agencies are sharing information and letting each other put the pieces together, surely terrorists will slip through their fingers.

But are duplication and stovepiping really bad things? A couple of other familiar concepts suggest not: markets and groupthink.

In markets, when there are multiple companies working to develop smartphones, no one complains about duplication of work. Of course not; we all understand the advantages of a market where firms can compete to bring us the best product. Even if competition for the almighty dollar is taken out of the picture, there are tons of examples of where we prefer to let many entities try out different solutions, knowing that some will work out better than others. Indeed that's one of the advantages of having 50 states acting as laboratories for public policy.

But building a better smartphone or experimenting with public policy is not the same as putting together information to stop potential acts of terrorism, one might respond. Unlike the smartphone and policy, there's no saying what's the best version, so trying out many kinds and seeing what sticks makes sense. But with terrorists, it's not like you're looking for theoretical terrorists - there are actual ones out there that you need to find, and fast. True, but while you can't experiment with hypothetical terrorists, you can experiment with how best to find them. Finding a terrorist needle in the haystack is as much art as science; it may be to our advantage if many groups of spooks are putting their minds together in different ways to find the bad guys - the more creative teams out there, the more likely one will find the bad guys before they find us.

Admittedly, the fact that so many agencies don't have access to each others' intelligence is more of a problem - but it could also be a good thing. Psychologists have long known that we have a number of biases that lead us to believe misinformation; "groupthink", "social proof", "confirmation bias" all predispose us to believe what others believe (without deeply questioning) and to believe only what fits our theories. Even more oddly, our instinct is just to believe things - so once we've heard something, even if we think "that can't be true", part of our brain takes it as truth. All of this adds up to one of our great cognitive traps - "the inadvertent acceptance of the nearly correct," as Janet Metcalfe calls it. In other words, we think more information equals more knowledge, but it paradoxically can lead to "overconfidence"; as we plateau or even lose knowledge we believe we know more.


Thursday, April 1, 2010

Any Team Will Do

Any one who's been to a sports game, knows the power of team spirit.

I was barely a baseball fan and one that could have cared less about the Mets when I was invited to the 6th game of the 1986 World Series. By the seventh inning I remember clasping my hands and praying that the Mets would win (I don't pray), and when Bill Buckner let an easy out roll through his legs, letting the Mets take the lead in the final innings I - along with 50,000 other possessed fans in Shea Stadium - responded as if Christ had descended onto right field (I don't believe in Christ either). I believe I haven't watched a Mets game since.

What happened in Queens that night, of course, happens in college basketball games and professional football games (of the US and World varieties) every day. Our ability to turn into writhing and screaming fanatics no doubt has much to do with the chemistry of the crowd. But at possibly a deeper level - and what the crowd taps into - is our remarkable urge to be on a team.

Any team will do. We're not limited to sports; political parties, schools, musical preferences, hair styles - and of course nations and religions - all give us plenty of opportunity to identify with a group and, because every game needs an opponent, take down the other guys.

Yesterday a thin, somewhat amusing New York Post article about New Yorkers turning their kitchens into closets turned into a battle ground for suburbanites and urbanistas to go to war against each other.

A suburban fired the first shot: "I feel sorry for these people, they're living like animals in a cage."

It was early in the game, so only a half-hearted volley came in response: "People living NYC are barely home. These apartments are just like hotel rooms where you hold your stuff and sleep every now and then."

But things were just heating up: "My bathroom is bigger than her apartment. I feel sorry for them They don't know how to live."

And then team NYC fully jumped into the fray: "For us Manhattan-ites, a tiny apartment in Manhattan is our heaven. A spacious Mc-Mansion in the suburbs would be our hell!"

Gloves were off: "Sooo, you never make coffee, never have a bottle of white wine you need to chill, never want cold water in summer, never even make toast? You obviously never entertain, or know the joys of a beautifully prepared romantic dinner. Never will enjoy the privacy of an intimate dinner for two; you would have share those moments with an entire restaurant."

And it just got uglier: "I can't imagine living in a city full of people willing to live in that city."

Ending with what almost sounds like a wishful thinking for city-cide? "I just wonder what will happen when some disaster closes the restaurants? Will you riot? Or just sit down and starve? NYC is only 4 hours from starvation. My house is 6 months."

Of course, we need to take a deep breath, remember that this is all just in response to a fluff article about a few people that store their shoes in their refrigerators and that the commenters are all, presumably, well off enough to afford homes with heating, electricity and running water - and are even fairly literate. I, who like to imagine myself a level-headed reasonable person, was even in the process of registering with then NYPost so I could come to the defense of my urban compadres -when I stopped myself (and wrote this post instead).

What is happening here? If we can so easily exercised over apartment sizes and residential choices, what else cannot get us up in arms? Not much. The power of identity - and of belonging to a team that shares that identity - will creep up wherever it can.

In a class I took last fall, the professor split us into two groups to play a 5 minute game. I won't go into the details of the game - but it wasn't very intense; none of us had to get out of our seats, most of us didn't even have to speak, and those that did speak only had to make a negotiation offer or accept/reject that offer. The game wasn't so interesting, but what was surprising was the immediate feelings that arose about the "other" side - that included disdain, distrust and even anger.

In that case the only thing to identify ourselves as part of the team was the professor saying "everyone on this side of the room is on team "A."